Cinnaholic Reviews

Cinnaholic has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 41 reviews. Customer feedback on Cinnaholic is mixed: Cinnaholic reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious and unique cinnamon rolls, customizable toppings, friendly customer service, vegan options, which strongly appeal to vegans, dessert lovers, families, foodies. However, Cinnaholic is often criticized for its higher price point, limited locations, potential wait times, inconsistent quality.

3.8/5.0

41 reviews

5 Stars

11

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

2

2 Stars

7

1 Star

0

All Cinnaholic Reviews (41)
david.Picklesimer
May 23, 2026
"So Many Ways to Make It Yours"
I love how customizable the rolls are on cinnaholic. Like, picking your frosting and toppings is the fun part, the fun part. There are so many options that everyone in my house ended up choosing something totally different. Ordering was easy, too, and my combo came out exactly how I wanted it. Super happy with it, super happy.
darin-Sweet
May 21, 2026
"Never consistent"
I keep giving them another chance and feel kind of stupid for trusting them at this point. Some locations are actually really good, but others mess up the toppings or the rolls like it’s a totally different place. I just wish it was more consistent.
KORT
May 20, 2026
"Cute rolls, but the packaging mystery continues"
The box was really cute and the rolls looked like they were meant to arrive all picture-perfect, but somewhere during delivery things got suspiciously chaotic. Frosting was stuck to the lid and sides like it had tried to escape, and I’m not saying the packaging and the delivery bumps were working together against me… but the evidence was there. They still looked tasty, just not as neat as I was expecting. A little stronger packaging would probably solve the whole case.
JanetConnolly_95
May 07, 2026
"I do like the rewards, they’re nice and..."
I do like the rewards, they’re nice and actually help when I order. The promos are useful too, especially on days when I’m already planning to grab something. I just wish there were more more deals available.
DavidSoolua
May 01, 2026
"Good first impression ordering online"
My first impression of ordering through cinnaholic.com was really good. The site was simple to use, even on my phone, and I didn’t have to hunt around to pick my rolls or add toppings. Checkout was quick too, which I always appreciate.
The only thing I did was double check my pickup time once, but that was no big deal. The confirmation email came right away, and when I got there, my order was ready. Easy experience overall, and I’d definitely use it again
hello_charles078
May 01, 2026
"Got my order and everything was actually correct…"
Got my order and everything was actually correct, which I always appreciate. No missing toppings or weird mix-ups, so that was a relief. It did take a little longer than I expected, but maybe that’s normal? Overall, I’d say it was a good experience
ReneeGibbs
April 26, 2026
"Pretty easy stop for a cinnamon roll"
I stopped by cinnaholic it was really easy to find. I was expecting parking to be kind of annoying, actually, no, it was super close, which made the whole thing way easier. I didn’t have to circle around or waste time, so it ended up being a nice little spot for a quick cinnamon roll run.
robert_Seely04
April 03, 2026
"Nice staff, quick fix"
The staff was really nice and got my order issue sorted out in maybe a few minutes or so. I’d probably give it 5 stars if it had been just a bit faster, but overall it was a good experience
hello_joan478
March 03, 2026
"Showed up right on time"
I’ve ordered from cinnaholic a couple times now, and the delivery has been really solid. Like, it actually shows up when it says it will, which shouldn’t feel rare but kind of does. The food was still fresh too, not all smashed around or anything, so that was a relief. I mostly just wanted something easy with no random delays, and that’s pretty much what I got
eugenesizemore5686
February 18, 2026
"Sweet Treat, Slight Parking Hassle"
I enjoyed my stop at cinnaholic overall. The rolls were really good and definitely felt like a nice little treat, but finding parking was more of a hassle than I expected. I ended up circling around for a bit, which took away from the quick-stop vibe I had in mind. Still, it reminded me that sometimes the small indulgences are worth a little extra effort—just maybe not when you’re in a rush.
CharlesColton_78
February 12, 2026
"it was worth the money. The portions were…"
it was worth the money. The portions were really good, and I left feeling satisfied
Rose-stover
February 11, 2026
"Felt a little shorted on the portion"
I really wanted to like this because the idea is fun and the flavors were decent, but the portion size threw me off. For the price, I expected the roll to be bigger or at least leave me feeling full, and instead I had that annoying feeling like I might’ve been fooled by the photos or description.
It looked nice when I opened the box, so at first I thought it would be fine, but once I started eating it just didn’t feel like enough. Maybe it depends on the location, but mine felt small enough that I probably wouldn’t order it again anytime soon.
Seth-slonaker
January 30, 2026
"Good Treat, Frustrating Wait"
I ordered from Cinnaholic thinking it’d be a quick little treat, but the wait ended up being annoying. They gave us one expectation, then it took way longer, and nobody really explained what was going on or bothered to update us. The place didn’t even seem that busy, so standing around not knowing when our order would be ready was frustrating. The food was good once we finally got it, but the poor communication and slow service definitely took the fun out of it. I probably wouldn’t come back if I was in any kind of hurry.
Robert_flanagan77
January 26, 2026
"Frosting was a little off"
The frosting tasted kind of weird to me , so it wasn’t really my favorite .
hello_antonio798
January 26, 2026
"I tried the pumpkin roll the other..."
I tried the pumpkin roll the other day because I was already in the mood for something fall-ish after running errands, and it was super good. Definitely planning to order it again soon.
MCNEIL
January 22, 2026
"Could’ve Been Cleaner"
I stopped in it just didn’t feel very clean inside. They could probably do a better job keeping up with it.
hello_gloria188
January 19, 2026
"Bulk order ended up being more stressful than I expected"
I ordered a bulk box for a small work event, it left me feeling mentally drained. The pickup time got pushed back, a few of the rolls were missing toppings, and it took a while to get responses over email. The food tasted fine once we had everything, but the whole catering setup just felt a bit unorganized and more hassle than I was hoping for
AnnetteMcneal
January 14, 2026
"Wish I had read the reviews first"
I really do like Cinnaholic, but this was frustrating. I tried ordering a specialty roll and a few toppings, and once again, a bunch of the stuff I wanted was out of stock. The site gets you all excited picking everything out, then you end up having to change half your order. The food is good when they actually have what you want, but the availability is a problem. I kind of wish I had read the reviews first so I knew this was something that happens a lot.
irma_Meyer88
January 06, 2026
"I really like how many options cinnaholic has..."
I really like how many options cinnaholic has. Like, you can switch up the frosting, add different toppings, and it doesn’t feel like you’re getting the same cinnamon roll every time. I went with my family and we all tried different combos, which was kind of the fun part. The menu has a lot going on, but it’s not overwhelming or confusing. Definitely a 5-star spot if you’re into variety.
SCOTT
January 03, 2026
"Way better than I expected"
I ordered from cinnaholic it was so much better than I thought it’d be. The rolls tasted really fresh, not dry or stale at all, and the toppings didn’t feel cheap or old. Everything had a ton of flavor, and you can definitely tell they care about quality. It was packed nicely too, which I appreciated. I’d totally order again, especially when I’m in the mood for something sweet

View More Reviews

Have a question about Cinnaholic?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.